John try unwilling to obfuscate the challenge also this much into the Sherlock’s visibility. John lets Sherlock believe he or she is upright, but he never closes one doorway totally: odd conclusion having a great heterosexual child, however, certainly realistic getting good bisexual kid that’s in search of a relationship which have Sherlock and expectations Sherlock you are going to change their mind. And while John cannot knowingly state “I am not saying gay” within earshot of Sherlock, Sherlock really does overhear John find out here claim that so you’re able to Irene in the A Scandal into the Belgravia – and John attempts to provides a discussion about it with Sherlock, and that is turn off.

Think of, John are prepared to kill visitors to stay close Sherlock, very definitely he’d feel ready to cover-up his sex as well

Better, for one thing, Sherlock did actually extremely hate the notion of John getting attracted so you can him. It’s a good idea John do just time ladies to store Sherlock out-of obtaining the impression. And, in the event that John attempted to time men they would imagine he was in search of Sherlock, but not unfairly. It makes the quintessential experience getting John to date girls, in which he does not appear to have a problem with they. (No matter if, getting fair, which have John you could potentially not be yes.) It’s easy getting bisexual visitors to alive heterosexual life: many people are heterosexual and imagine everyone else is also, therefore heterosexual matchmaking ventures pop up without needing to feel wanted out.

However, as to the reasons wasn’t John already unlock about this, and why really does he obfuscate the situation to his cousin and Expenses Murray? Really, there are hints to help you a lot more factors in these very early weblog records. John is actually called a females guy prior to getting mailed away so you can Afghanistan, plus in The sign of Around three the audience is displayed the type from Big Sholto, men which John greatly admires and has now a number of the same unsociable attributes Sherlock have; maybe the caretaker from inside the John try attracted to people who appear emotionally injured and you may skittish.

Along with wider terms and conditions, it will be unsurprising in the event the John’s gay side stumbled on this new fore as he was at the new military and you will generally enclosed by guys – and even, about Manifestation of About three we are going to be provided with biggest gay contacts toward military, and Major Sholto particularly. In addition to, the fresh let you know tend to strengthen more than once you to intercourse try vital that you John. When the John has any destination at all in order to boys, it is not unreasonable to trust he’d work inside it inside the an enthusiastic environment in which there were couples available females.

The quintessential informing issue, yet not, would be the fact John’s audience of these “I am not saying homosexual” times has never been Sherlock, actually even though Sherlock thought John try hitting towards the him in the 1st event and other people continually guess they truly are one or two

So what happened during the Afghanistan? We do not understand, but it is not really difficult to speculate. Possibly John did not reach work inside, in which he will not can identify. Possibly it actually was unrequited, and he feels sad or bitter contemplating unsociable people. Maybe it absolutely was requited and you will concluded badly. Possibly the guy performed operate on it however, there is certainly tension so you’re able to keep it secret and you can, having just came back about war, he’s not really yes how-to go about getting discover regarding it given their previous profile along with his old family being odd regarding it – maybe not an unusual material in the event you turn out later in the lifetime, and you may Expenses and you can Harry appear to find the idea comedy. To make bull crap about the idea that John was gay was not more sensitive and painful environment they could has actually built in the event the John wished to come out. Or perhaps John informed himself it was only because girls weren’t readily available, but he is just starting to read maybe it was more one to. Possibly the guy will favor women, and guys need to really be a present. Maybe he wishes students; John seems happier sufficient when he finds out out-of Mary’s pregnancy in The unmistakeable sign of Three. It is far from at all strange to possess bisexual boys for sex which have males however, merely go after matchmaking having women this is why.